
Osteoporosis Treatment - A Practical Guideline
Skeletal disorder characterised by compromised bone strength predisposing to an increased risk of fracture
WHO estimates 70 million people suffering from osteoporosis
Hip Fractures
- most severe complication
- worldwide incidence of 1.5 million annually
- 20% end up in nursing homes
- 20% mortality within 1 year of fracture
- 2/3 never return to pre-fracture functional level
Fragility Fractures (USA, Northern Europe and S.E. Asia data)
- Hips 20% age at 70s
- Spine 50% age at 60s
- Wrist 30% age at 50s
Children
- Overlooked at-risk group
- Strategy - achieve maximal bone mass during bone development period
- Decrease risk of osteoporosis at later life
- Primary health - stress diet & physical activity
- Osteoporosis is a paediatric disease with a geriatric outcome (Kitchin & Morgan 2003)
Lifestyle Factors
- Physical activity increases bone mass by increasing muscle mass - thus increasing stress on bone
- Obese individuals or high muscle mass individuals tend to have higher bone mass
- Smoking & alcohol decreases bone mass
Calcium & Vit D
- Recommended daily dosage:
- 800mg
children ages 1-10 - 1000mg
male
pre-menopausal women,
post-menopausal women on HT - 1200mg
teenages & young adults 11-24 - 1500mg
post-menopausal women not on estrogen - 1200mg to 1500mg
Pregnant & nursing mothers
- Post-menopausal women desiring to reduce risk of osteoporosis should consume 1000 to 1500mg of elemental calcium with 400-800 IU of vitamin D (NIH Consensus Development Panel on Optimal Calcium Intake, 1994)
Calcium Intake
- Should not exceed 2500mg a day
- Offers no health benefit
- May cause hypocalcaemia & hypercalciuria
- Calcium carbonate or Caltrate
600mg of calcium with 200 IU vit D per tab
Taken as 1 tablet bd with food - Calcium citrate or Citracal
315mg of calcium with 200 IU vit D per tab
Taken as 2 tablets bd with food
Diagnosis of Osteoporosis

BMD - Who Needs It
- All women > 65 years
- Post-menopausal woman with major risk factors
- All individuals > 50 years with history of osteoporotic fracture
- All individuals on long term steroids
- Men with hypogonadal conditions
- Men > 70 years
- Patients with diseases a/w bone loss and fracture
Treatment Guidelines
- T-score is < -2.5
- T-score is < -1.5 with a major risk factor
- Major risk factor:-
Personal history of fracture
Family history of fracture
Current cigarette smoker
Weight < 127 lbs
Pharmacotherapy
- “Hormones”
Oestrogens
SERMS
rPTH
Calcitonins - Strontium ranelate
- Biphosphonates
Alendronate
Risedronate
Ibandronate
Zoledronic acid
Secondary Causes
- Pharmcotherapy eg steroids, phenytoin
- Endocrine disorders eg Cushing’s
- GI disorders eg eating disorders
- Genetic disorders eg OI
- Miscellaneous eg organ transplant, RA
Evaluation for 2o causes
- History & Physical Examination
25-OH Vit D
Serum Calcium
Serum phosphorus, Alk phosphatase, Cre
Parathyroid hormone
Thyroid function test
Serum protein electrophoresis
Serum testosterone in men
Estrogen Therapy or HT
- Inhibits bone resorption and increases BMD
Binds to estrogen receptors on bone
Blocks production of cytokines that increases osteoclasts
Many different formulations and applications
Reduced vertebral (33%) and non-vertebral (27%) fractures
Torgerson 2001
Current Indications for HT
- 2nd line treatment due to risk for breast and endometrial cancers
Only for post-menopausal women who cannot tolerate non-estrogen medications
To be used with the lowest dose possible and for the shortest period of time to achieve treatment goals
SERMs Raloxifene
- Selective estrogen receptor modulators
Binds to estrogen receptors
Estrogen agonist activity on bone and circulating lipoproteins
Estrogen antagonist activity on breast and endometrial tissues
Increased risk for DVT
Does not block vasomotor symptoms of menopause
Raloxifene
- Increased spine BMD by 2.3% and hip BMD by 2.5% after 3 years
50% reduction in spine fractures
No effect on hip or other non-vertebral fractures
Cranney 2002, Black 1999
- 60mg coated tablets taken once daily
Must be stopped 72 hours prior to and during prolonged immobilisation
Decreased absorption with ampicillin
Calcitonin
- Using salmon’s calcitonin due to prolonged action and greater potency compared to mammalian source
Intra-nasal spray
Analgesic effect
Not appropriate as 1st line treatment
Only used as 2nd or 3rd line treatment in patients who cannot tolerate bisphosphonates
Inhibits osteoclast activity and osteoclast lifespan
Calcitonin 200 IU
- 33% reduction in new vertebral fractures
36% reduction in those with history of previous fractures
PROOF study
Chesnut 2000
No effect on non-vertebral fractures
Parathyroid Hormone
- Stimulates osteoblast activity
Recombinant PTH - teriparatide or Forteo
Once-daily subcutaneous injection in a 28-day kit
Can be used up to 24 months
Indicated in:
Patients with very high risk of future vertebral fractures
Those who failed to respond to bisphosphonate
Recombinant PTH
- 83% reduction in moderate to severe vertebral fracture risk in men on 20mcg daily
Kaufman 2005
65% reduction in new vertebral fractures in women on 20mcg daily
Neer 2001
53% reduction in non-vertebral fracture risk
Gallagher, Vargas 2005, Neer 2001
- May cause orthostatic hypotension - 1st dose given supine
Very expensive - 10x cost of bisphosphonate treatment
Can be used sequentially or together with bisphosphonates
Strontium Ranelate “Protos”
- Act on osteoblasts to increase bone formation
Increases osteoprotegerin which reduces the number and activity of osteoclasts to decrease bone resorption
Less problem with suppression of remodeling and over-mineralisation
Strontium Ranelate
- 41% reduction in vertebral fractures over 3 years
Seeman 2008 (Pooled data from SOTI & TROPOS Trials)
43% reduction in hip fractures over 5 years
Reginster 2007 (TROPOS Trial)
Strontium Ranelate Vertebral Fractures
- 41-59% fracture risk reduction in patients with osteopaenia with or without a prevalent fracture
Seeman 2008
Strontium Ranelate
- Taken 1 satchet daily at bed-time
Reported to have DRESS syndrome
rare occurrence, only in Europe
Biphosphonates
- Biphosphonates
Inhibits osteoclasts to decrease bone resorption and allows osteoblasts to slightly increase BMD
1st line therapy for osteoporosis
Examples
Alendronate (Fosamax) - has 10-year f/up studies
Risedronate (Actonel)
Ibandronate (Bonviva)


Bisphosphonates
- Poor bioavailability - < 1% absorbed on oral intake
Drastically reduced if taken with or around meal times
Not to be taken together with calcium supplements
Alendronate 10mg Daily - Vertebral Fractures
- 48% relative risk reduction in 994 post-menopausal patients with T < -2.5 regardless of history of fractures
Lieberman 1995Fracture Intervention Trial I & II
FIT I (with h/o fractures) RRR - 47%
Black 1996
FIT II (without h/o fractures) RRR - 45%
Cummings 1998
Alendronate 70mg Once A Week “Fosamax”
- Comparable efficacy to 10mg daily dosing
Schnitzer 2000
Risedronate 5mg Daily “Actonel”
- Vertebral Efficacy with Risedronate Therapy or VERT trials
65% RRR at 1 year
41% RRR at 3 year
Harris 1999
61% RRR at 1 year
49% RRR at 3 year
Reginster 2000
Risedronate 5mg Daily
- Hip Intervention Programme
9000 patients
Reduction in Hip fractures
60% at 3 years
Harris NEJM 2001
Risedronate 35mg Once A Week
- Comparable efficacy to 5mg daily dosing
Brown 2002
Ibandronate “Bonviva”
- Newest oral bisphophonate
2.5mg daily dosing and 150mg once a month dosing
Vertebral fracture prevention data only for 2.5mg daily dosing
Chestnut 2004, Felsenberg 2005, Miller 2005
Zoledronic Acid “Aclasta”
- A single annual 5mg IV infusion has been shown to decrease morphometric vertebral fractures by 70% over a 36 month period
- Hip fracture relative risk reduction of 41%
- Non-vertebral relative risk reduction of 25%
Zoledronic Acid Demonstrated Broad Efficacy in Women With Postmenopausal Osteoporosis
- In women with postmenopausal osteoporosis, once yearly infusion of ZOL 5 mg over 3 years significantly reduces
Vertebral fractures (morphometric 70%, clinical 77%)(1)
Hip fractures (41%)(1)
Non-vertebral fractures (25%)(1)
Days of disability due to fracture or back pain(2)
Height loss(1)
Significantly superior to placebo in increasing or preserving BMD(1)
Markers of bone formation and resorption were reduced and maintained within premenopausal reference range over 36 months(1)
Generally well tolerated(1)
Fracture efficacy coupled with high adherence suggests potential role for ZOL 5 mg as treatment for osteoporosis(1)
- 1. Black DM, et al. N Engl J Med. 2007;356:1809-1822.
- 2. Black DM, et al. Presented at: ASBMR 28th Annual Meeting; September 15-19, 2006; Philadelphia, Pa. Abstract 1054.








Practical Points
- Patient compliance
Avoids heart-burn, oesophagitis
Proven to work
Zoledronic Acid
- Side effects include:
Pyrexia, myalgia, influenza-like symptoms
Headache, arthralgia
Usually lasts 2 – 3 days - Serious AF in 2.4% of study population
AF in Zoledronic Acid
- HORIZON PFT trial – 2.4% increased incidence of AF seen in ZA group
- But this was not found in the 2nd large trial HORIZON RFT
Nor in the clinical trials with Zometa in over 20,000 patients
Non-Vertebral Fractures
- Alendronate & risedronate effective in preventing non-vertebral fractures
- Fosamax International Study Trial Group FOSIT- 51% reduction in hip fractures
Pols 1999 - Meta-analysis of Fosamax for prevention of hip fractures in post-menopausal women showed 55% overall risk reduction
- Hip Intervention Program HIP study - RRR 36% with Alendronate 5mg om vs placebo
McClung 2001 - Ibandronate - evidence still lacking
Subtrochanteric Insufficiency Fractures
- Associated with patients on long-term (>2.5 years) alendronate therapy
- Tend to be “younger” (age 60s) and socially active
- Fractures at the metaphyseal-diaphyseal junctions
- Prodromal symptoms
- Due to prolonged suppression of bone remodeling
Goh 2007
You should speak with your Orthopaedic doctor regarding the best treatment for you.
________________________________________________________
| Sign Up For Our Email Newsletter And Receive, Among Other Things, Tips And Strategies To Prevent Serious Joint & Sports Injuries. Plus, Answers To Readers' Questions. Your Email Is Safe With Us. We Respect Your Email Privacy. |
________________________________________________________
















